Choosing between Zanzibar vs Mauritius vs Maldives can be tricky — all three promise turquoise waters, warm weather, and unforgettable island escapes. But each destination offers a very different travel experience. Whether you’re planning a romantic honeymoon, a kitesurfing holiday, or a budget-friendly beach break, this guide will help you decide which island is right for you.

Zanzibar: Culture, Adventure & Affordable Luxury

Why Choose Zanzibar

Zanzibar is perfect for travellers who want more than just beaches. The island blends history, spice-trade culture, world-class kitesurfing, vibrant local markets, and beautiful coastline.

Who Zanzibar Is Best For

• Couples looking for romance without Maldives prices

• Adventure travellers and water-sports lovers

• Families wanting space and affordability

• Travellers who want cultural experiences and nature combined

Highlights of Zanzibar

• Stone Town – a UNESCO World Heritage Site

• Kitesurfing in Paje, one of the best spots in the world, like ZanzibarKitesurfing

• Wildlife encounters, including dolphin tours and Jozani Forest

• Affordable boutique villas

• Lively nightlife in Paje, Kendwa, and Nungwi

Mauritius: Family-Friendly, Polished & Resort-Focused

Why Choose Mauritius

Mauritius is known for its well-developed infrastructure, luxury resorts, green mountains, and family-friendly beaches. It is the most “Western-style” of the three islands.

Who Mauritius Is Best For

• Families with kids or multigenerational trips

• Travellers who prefer organised tours and resort-style holidays

• Divers and snorkellers

• Visitors who want a calm, predictable, safe destination

Highlights of Mauritius

• Stunning lagoons protected by coral reefs

• Hiking trails in Black River Gorges National Park

• A wide choice of all-inclusive resorts

• Very safe and easy to get around

• Beautiful botanical gardens and viewpoints

Maldives: Private Islands & Ultimate Luxury

Why Choose the Maldives

If your dream holiday involves overwater villas, endless blue lagoons, and complete privacy, the Maldives is unmatched. However, it is also the most expensive option.

Who the Maldives Is Best For

• Honeymooners seeking luxury and seclusion

• Couples celebrating a special occasion

• Travellers who want the “postcard-perfect” experience

• Visitors who prefer relaxing over exploring

Highlights of the Maldives

• Iconic overwater bungalows

• Unbelievable snorkelling and diving

• Quiet, peaceful lagoons

• Perfect for short, high-end stays

• Excellent spa and wellness retreats

Price Comparison: Which Island Fits Your Budget? 

Zanzibar

Most affordable option.
Boutique villas, mid-range resorts, and local restaurants keep costs down.

Mauritius

Mid-high cost.
Luxury resorts dominate, but some mid-range options exist.

Maldives

Most expensive.
Resorts charge premium rates for rooms, meals, transfers, and activities.

Best Time to Visit Zanzibar vs Mauritius vs Maldives

Zanzibar

• Best: June–October

• Also great: December–February

• Avoid heavy rains in April & May

Mauritius

• Best: May–December

• Cyclone season: January–March

Maldives

• Best: November–April

• Wet season: May–October

Zanzibar vs Mauritius vs Maldives: Quick Comparison Table

Final Verdict: Which Island Should You Choose?

• Choose Zanzibar if you want culture, adventure, affordability, and stunning beaches. (Perfect for couples, families, and kitesurfers.)

• Choose Mauritius if you’re seeking a polished, easy, family-friendly island with beautiful resorts and diverse landscapes.

• Choose the Maldives if you want luxury, privacy, romance, and bucket-list overwater villas.

If you’re dreaming of turquoise waters, soft white sands, and a perfect blend of relaxation and adventure — Zanzibar is the most well-rounded, best-value choice.
And if you’re staying in beautiful Paje, check out Paje Villas Zanzibar for a modern, peaceful beach escape.

Also read Why Paje, one of our other blogs about the beautiful town we call home.